A librarian who hosts a murder mystery club at work finds people connected to the group are being killed off one by one in copycats of the true-crime books they discuss.

When Aurora shows a house for her realtor mom, the handsome client finds the body of a rival realtor in the backyard. Suspicion falls on all realtors. Aurora starts investigating with help from her friends.

Aurora buys a house where the previous tenants, the Julius family, disappeared 4 years ago - something that excites Aurora and her friends in Real Murders Club. They start investigating.

Aurora hosts Martin's niece and her newborn for the night, but then his niece disappears, the baby is found hidden in the bathtub and Aurora discovers a stranger in her linen closet, along with $10,000 cash in a diaper bag.

When a Hollywood film crew comes to shoot in Lawrenceton, and the film's star is found poisoned and bludgeoned in her dressing room, crime-solving librarian Aurora Teagarden enlists members...

When Aurora finds Poppy murdered in her home, the "Real Crime" club members gather to discuss the case and end with four suspects and four motives.

Aurora's a librarian, sleuth and bridesmaid at Lizzie's wedding, where Lizzie's rich aunt dies from poisoning. The will is a bad surprise for the son. Aurora and Real Murders Club investigate.

Aurora and friends are off to a resort for a true crime convention. While there, they take part in a mystery dinner theater. But art imitates life when a fellow actor gets killed.